99¦~09¤ë¸¹ ¹D ªk ªk °T (221)

DEEP & FAR

 

 

¶i¨B©Ê¶·¨Ìªk»{©w

(Federal Circuit 2008-1073) (¤T)

 

 

³¯ºaºÖ ±M§Q¥N²z¤H

¡E¤¤°êÂåÃľǰ|ÃľǨt¾Ç¤h

¡E¤é¥»ºÖ©£¤j¾Ç¥ÍÃľǩҺӤh

¡E¶§©ú¤j¾ÇÂå¾ÇÃIJz©Ò³Õ¤h

 

 

¸Ó·»¾¯¥i·»¸ÑÃĪ«¡A¥O¨ä±q©³¼hÂX´²¨ì³»¼h¡C¦]¦¹¡A·íCypher¤ä¬[¦b·Àµß³B²z¡A¥HÒç°£©Ò¦³³Ñ¾l¤§·»¾¯®É¡AÃĪ«¶i¤J³»¼h¤§µ{«×¡A¥O³»¼h©M©³¼h¥]§t¬Û¦P¿@«×¤§ÃĪ«¡C©ó·Àµß«á³»¼h¤ñ©³¼h¸ûÁ¡;¤j¬ù¥]§t·Àµß«á¤ä¬[Á`ÃĪ«¶q¤§23%¡C

©ó¸ÕÅç®É¡A³­¼f¹Î®Ú¾Ú²ßª¾§Þ³N¸ê®Æ¡A¨Ò¦p¬ü°ê±M§Q²Ä5,545,208¸¹(Wolff)[1]©M±M§Q²Ä5,512,055¸¹(Domb)[2]¡A»{©w¡¦536±M§Q¤§½Ð¨D²Ä8¶µ¨Ã«DÅã¦Ó©öª¾¡C³­¼f¹Î¤]»{©wCypher¤ä¬[«I¥Ç½Ð¨D²Ä8¶µ¡C©ó¼f§P«á¡BCordis¥Ó½Ð¤§JMOL§ó·s½Ð¨D[3]¡A©Î¥t¤@¦¸­«·s¼f²z«IÅv©M¦³®Ä©Ê¡CCordis¤§½Ð¨D³Qªk°|§_»{¡C

¦p¦¹¬°¤§®É¡A´NDomb¡BWolff©M¨ä¥L°Ñ¦Ò¸ê®Æ¦Ó¨¥¡A¦a¤èªk°|ºû«ù³­¼f¹Î«DÅã¦Ó©öª¾¤§»{©w¡Cªk°|»{¬°Domb¤w´¦¥Ü­¹ºÞ¤ä¬[¡A¥¼·t¥Ü¤ä¬[¨Ï¥Îª÷ÄÝ¡A¥B¨ÃµLµ²¦XDomb»P¨ä¥L¬ÛÃö¸ê®Æ¤§ÃÒ¾Ú[4]¡Cªk°|®Ú¾Ú¤@¦ì±M®a·N¨£¡A¦Ó½×Â_Wolff¨ÃµL±Ð¥Ü¤@ª÷Äݤä¬[¦³¤G¼h¶î¼h¡A¥B¸gWolff¨üÅý¤H©ó¶W¹L¤Q¦~¤§¹ê§@«á¡A¥¼¯à³Ð³y¥X½Ð¨D¤§¤ä¬[¡A¥iÃÒ©ú¯Ê¥Fµ²¦X¦UºØ²ßª¾§Þ³N¤ä¬[¯SÂI¤§°Ê¾÷¡C[5]

²×©ó§@¬°«DÅã¦Ó©öª¾¤§¦¸­n¦Ò¼{¡Aªk°|¨Ì¾Ú±M®a¤§ÃÒµü»{©wCypher¤§¤ä¬[³QºÙ³\©M°Ó·~¦¨¥\«YÂk¦]©ó­n¨D¶µ¤§¯SÂI¡A¥B§Y¨Ï©ó¿ë»{¤@ºØ¾A·í¤§ÃĪ«©M¤ä¬[«á¡ACordis»Ý­n«Ü¦h®É¶¡¥h¶}µo¶îÃÄ«¬¤ä¬[¡C[6]

 
 
 

  



[1]. December 21, 1993¥Ó½Ð08/171,361¡A©óAugust 13, 1996¤½§i¡A¨üÅý¤HMedtronic,Inc.¡A±M§Q¦WºÙIntralumenal drug eluting prosthesis

[2]. September 30, 1994¥Ó½Ð08/316,067¡A©óApril 30, 1996¤½§i¡A¨üÅý¤HBloom;Leonard¡A±M§Q¦WºÙAnti-infective and anti- inflammatory releasing systems for medical devices

[3]. judgment as a matter of law

[4]. Opinion Denying JMOL, 434 F. Supp. 2d at 320.

[5]. Id.

[6]. Id. at 321.