100¦~05¤ë¸¹ ¹D ªk ªk °T (229)

DEEP & FAR

 

 

¶i¨B©Ê¶·¨Ìªk»{©w(¤Q¤@)

(Federal Circuit 2008-1073)

 

³¯ºaºÖ ±M§Q¥N²z¤H

¡E¤¤°êÂåÃľǰ|ÃľǨt¾Ç¤h

¡E¤é¥»ºÖ©£¤j¾Ç¥ÍÃľǩҺӤh

¡E¶§©ú¤j¾ÇÂå¾ÇÃIJz©Ò³Õ¤h

 

 

®Ú¾ÚCordis¡Aµ²¦X«á¡A¨ä¥ç«Y´¦¥ÜµÛ¨C¤@­­¨î¡C²×©ó¡ACordisª§ÅGºÙ¡AÃÒ¤H´y­z¶}µoCypher¦­©ó¡¦536±M§Q¤§Àu¥ýÅv¤é¥B·í®É¶È´y­z¶îÂбa¦³¤G­Ó©Ò½Ð¨D¶î¼h¤ä¬[®É¸û®e©ö¡CCordisª§ÅGºÙ¡A¸g¥ÑKSRÃþ«¬«e¤ÀªR(pre-KSR¡Vtype analysis)¡Aªi¤h¹y¬ì§Þ±M®a¨Ì¾a¤@¹L«×§C¶¥§Þ¯à¤ô·Ç¡A¦ÓÂ_¨¥¸Ó²ßª¾§Þ³N¨Ã¥¼©ú½T¦a«Øij¥i¾É­P©Ò½Ð¨Dµo©ú¤§­×§ï¡C[1]Ãö©ó«DÅã¦Ó©ö¨£¤§¦¸­n¦Ò¼{¡ACordisª§½×¨ºªi¤h¹y¬ì§Þ¨Ã¥¼±NCypher¤§¦¨¥\³s©ó»E¦Xª«¶î¼h¡C

ªi¤h¹y¬ì§Þ¦^À³ºÙWolff¨Ã¥¼»{ª¾¹ê½è¤WµLÃĪ«¤§³»¼h©Ò§e²{ÃB¥~¤§µL¦å¤pªOÂHªþ¡A«YÀu©ó§tÃĪ«¤§³»¼h¡A¦]¦¹¤£¯à¨ÏµL¦å¤pªOÂHªþ¤§µLÃĪ«³»¼h¤§½Ð¨D¶µ²Ä8¶µ¨ãÅã¦Ó©ö¨£©Ê¡Cªi¤h¹y¬ì§Þ¥çª§ÅGºÙ¡AWolff¥u´¦¥Ü³æ¤@¶î¼h¡A¥BWolff¨Ã¥¼´¦¥ÜµL¾®¦å¬¡©Ê¡CÁöµMWolff´¦¥Üª¿½¦©M»E®òà­§@¬°³»¼h§÷®Æ¡Aªi¤h¹y¬ì§ÞÂ_¨¥©ó¦¹µ¥§÷®Æ¨Ã¤£©T¦³¨ã³ÆµL¾®¦å¬¡©Ê¡A¦]¬°µL¾®¦å¬¡©Ê«Y¨ú¨M©ó¦p¦h¤Õ©Ê¤§ªí­±©Ê½è¡Cªi¤h¹y¬ì§Þ¸É¥R»¡¡ACordis§ÜÅG»P¥»¨­©óµL¾®¦å¬¡©Ê«Y¥¼«IÅv¤§½×ÂI¬Û¥Ù¬Þ¡A¦]¦¹³­¼f¹ÎÅÞ¿è¤W±o»é¦^¨âªÌ¤§¥ß³õ¡Cªi¤h¹y¬ì§Þ¥çª§ÅGºÙ¡A Domb¥ç¥¼´¦¥Ü¤@µL¦å¤pªOÂHªþ¤§³»¼h¡A¦]Domb¤ä¬[«Y¥Î©ó­¹¹D¡A¥¼±µÄ²¥i¾É­P¦å®ê§Î¦¨¤§´`Àô©Ê¦å²G¡C®Ú¾Úªi¤h¹y¬ì§Þ·N¨£¡ADomb¥ç¥¼±Ð¥Üª÷ÄÝ©Ê©Î¥i¦ùÁY¤§¤ä¬[¡Cªi¤h¹y¬ì§Þ§ó¥[¶iª§ÅGºÙ¡ADomb±Ð¥Ü¤@¶}©ñ©Ê¬]®æµ²ºc¡A¦]¬°¶}±Ò¤@¶}©ñ©Ê¬]®æ¥i«P¨Ï²Õ´¦V¤º¦¨ªø¡A¦ÓDomb¤ä¬[«h³]­p¦¨¥i²¾°£¡C

 

  



[1]. See KSR Int¡¦l Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007).