100¦~09¤ë¸¹ ¹D ªk ªk °T (233)

DEEP & FAR

 

 

¶i¨B©Ê¶·¨Ìªk»{©w(¤Q¤­)

(Federal Circuit 2008-1073)

 

³¯ºaºÖ ±M§Q¥N²z¤H

¡E¤¤°êÂåÃľǰ|ÃľǨt¾Ç¤h

¡E¤é¥»ºÖ©£¤j¾Ç¥ÍÃľǩҺӤh

¡E¶§©ú¤j¾ÇÂå¾ÇÃIJz©Ò³Õ¤h

 

 

§Ú­Ì¦P·NCordis¤§·N¨£¡A¤@¯ë¼ô±x¸Ó¶µ§ÞÃÀ¤H¤h±N¦³»¤¦]¡A©óµ²¦XWolff ¹Ï3B»P¹Ï4¤§¹ê¬I¨Ò¦ÓÀò­P¤@±a¦³¤G¶î¼h¤§ª÷Äݤä¬[¡C±N¤@²ßª¾§Þ³N±M§Q©Ò´¦¥Ü¤§¤G¬Û¾F¹ê¬I¨Ò¥[¥Hµ²¦X¡A®Ú¥»µL¶·³Ð³y¤O¡C¦pCordis¤§¹Ï©ÒÅã¥Ü³¡¤À¥H¤ÎWolff¤§»¡©ú®Ñ©Ò´y­z¡A¸Ó¹Ï´y­z¤@±a¦³¶îÃÄ«¬»E¦Xª«¶î¼h¤§ª÷Äݤä¬[¡A14«h¥Nªí¶î¼h¡C[1]©ó±M§Q¹Ï3B¡Aª½±µ¦a©ñ¸m©ó¹Ï4¤§¤U¤è¡AÅã¥Ü¤@­Ó¶îÃÄ«¬¤§»E¦Xª«¤ä¬[¡A¥ç¥H¼Æ¦r14¥Nªí¡A¥H¡u²Ä¤G¼h»E¦Xª«15¡v¥[¥H¶î¼h¡C[2]¤@¯ë¼ô±x¸Ó¶µ§ÞÃÀ¤H¤h±N³Q¿Eµo¥H²Ä¤G¼h»E¦Xª«¥[¥H¶î¼h¹Ï4¤§ª÷Äݤä¬[¡A¦Ó¥]¬A±a¦³ÃĪ«¤§»E¦Xª«¸Ó¼h14¡A¦p¦P©ó¹Ï3B©Ò´y­z¤§¼h15¡A¨ä«Y¹ê½è¤WµLÃĪ«ÄÀ¥X¤§§÷®Æ¡C¦p¦P©ó¹Ï3B¤ä¬[«Y¨ü´f©óÂù¼h¡A¨ä¤@§tÃĪ«¥B¥t¤@«h­­¨î¸ÓÃĪ«¤§ÂX´²¡A¾É­P¹Ï4¤§¤ä¬[¦P¼Ë¦a©ÓŧµÛ¸ÓÂù¶î¼h¤§ÀuÂI¡C¤@ª÷Äݤä¬[¥H¤@¶îÃÄ«¬»E¦Xª«¥[¥H¶î¼h¥H¤Î¤@µLÃĪ«ÄÀ¥X»E¦Xª«¤§²Ä¤G¼h¡A¦p¹Ï3B©M4©ÒÅã¥Ü¡A«Yºc¦¨½Ð¨D¶µ²Ä8¶µ¡C

§Ú­Ì¤]¦P·NCordisÃö©ó«DÅã¦Ó©öª¾¤§Á¡®z¦¸­n¦Ò¼{¡A«YµLªk§JªAWolff¡A°µ¦¨¡¦536±M§Q½Ð¨D¶µ²Ä8¶µÅã¦Ó©ö¨£¤§±j¯Pªí­±ÄÀ©ú¡C§Y¨ÏMedtronic¾Ö¦³Wolff¤§±M§Q»P¨ä¥L¤G­Ó²ßª¾§Þ³N¤§±M§Q(¦¹«YCordis©Ò¨Ì¾a¥B¨Ã¥¼¶}µo¶îÃÄ«¬¤ä¬[)¡ACordis´£¥X«Y¥X©óÃø¥Hµo²{¤@¾A·íÃĪ«¤§ÃÒ¾Ú¡A¦Ó«DµLªk³]­p¤@¥]§tÃĪ«©³¼h¨Ã»PµLÃĪ«³»¼h¤§µ²¦X¡C

  



[1]. See Wolff col.6 ll.59¡V62.

[2]. Id. at col.9 ll.25¡V26.